LK-99, Part 6: Kim and Kwon’s Later Research
After the 2023 LK-99 preprints, Hyun-Tak Kim and Young-Wan Kwon pursued separate research projects. This article follows Kim’s published work and Kwon’s account of the original submission and later LKK-17 announcement.
His Account of the Collaboration and His Role
On August 10, 2025, ZDNet Korea published an article based on a lengthy email sent directly by Dr. Hyun-Tak Kim. It included his account of joining the LK-99 project and his future plans, along with questions and answers exchanged by email.[1]
Kim said that Dr. Sukbae Lee had asked him to evaluate the research and write an English-language paper, leading him to join the collaboration.
He went on to describe working with another Korean team on PCPOSOS, a sulfur-containing follow-up candidate material. In discussing that work, he also addressed his relationship with the Quantum Energy Research Centre, or QERC:
“However, I am not currently conducting joint research with QERC.”
This statement describes his account of the collaboration as of 2025.[1] When asked whether the original team should have waited until its findings were more complete before publishing, Kim argued that chemistry alone had limited how far QERC could develop the work. He strongly emphasized the contribution of his interpretation as a physicist.[1]
The article also discussed nanovolt-level readings in connection with PCPOSOS measurements. A nanovolt is a unit of voltage; electrical resistance is measured in ohms. Assessing the significance of a very small voltage reading requires information about the applied current and the measurement conditions as well.[1][2]
A Room-Temperature Quantum Computer and the Resources to Pursue It
Kim’s interests extended beyond superconducting materials to a proposed quantum computer operating at room temperature. In his email, he described his research philosophy as “World first, World best, World service” and expressed a critical view of the prospects for existing superconducting, trapped-ion, and photonic approaches.[1] He said that, before retiring from ETRI, he had asked the Korean government to support the work with 20 billion won per year for ten years.
In his closing response, he encouraged younger researchers and said that securing funding through the Hyun-Tak Research Institute might allow him to pursue his plans.[1] The American Physical Society’s conference archive subsequently lists a presentation by Kim on March 18, 2026, proposing a MOSFET-based quantum computer operating at room temperature and ambient pressure. ZDNet Korea reported on the presentation on March 20.[3][4]
The APS abstract suggests that advanced semiconductor fabrication processes could enable chips with more than one million qubits. The million-qubit figure describes the intended scale of the proposed architecture.[3]
What the 2026 Superconductivity Report Covered
On September 27, 2026, ZDNet Korea reported on Dr. Hyun-Tak Kim’s research proposing an explanation for spontaneous supercurrents through shear stress and structural symmetry breaking.[5] The publisher’s record shows that the paper appeared online in the Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics on September 22, 2026.
Kim is the sole listed author, with an affiliation in the Department of Physics at William & Mary in the United States.[6] The abstract connects structural changes caused by shear stress with bipolarons, charge-density waves, and overlapping wave functions. It proposes a mechanism for spontaneous supercurrents and the superconducting diode effect, continuing the line of research discussed in my earlier posts on Kim’s superconductivity theory.[6]
This report concerns a proposed theoretical explanation for how supercurrents arise. The paper’s title and abstract do not establish that an independent reproduction of LK-99 superconductivity has succeeded.
The Submission Records of the Two Original Papers
Returning to July 22, 2023, the original arXiv records show the order in which the two LK-99 papers were submitted. The first was “The First Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor.” Its three authors were Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon. The submission record names Kwon as the submitter and gives the time as 07:51:19 UTC.[7]
Approximately two hours and twenty minutes later, at 10:11:28 UTC, Hyun-Tak Kim submitted the second paper. Its first version listed six authors: Sukbae Lee, Jihoon Kim, Hyun-Tak Kim, Sungyeon Im, SooMin An, and Keun Ho Auh. Young-Wan Kwon was not among them.[8]
These records establish the submission order and the authors listed at the time. Understanding why Kwon chose to submit first also requires examining his later explanation and the differing accounts of what happened within the research team.
Kwon’s Explanation for Posting First
On December 11, 2023, Dr. Young-Wan Kwon held a press conference to discuss the findings of Korea University’s Research Integrity Committee and explain his position. According to Hankook Ilbo’s account of the committee decision presented at the press conference, Kwon believed that publication of the six-author paper would prevent him from publishing the research results in which he had participated.
The reporting also showed that the researchers gave differing accounts of their contributions and the process of preparing and releasing the papers.[9] Etoday reported that the committee did not find the allegations under review to constitute research misconduct. In particular, it found no objective evidence supporting the allegation that Kwon had rushed to publish a paper with fewer authors to secure publication priority.
However, the committee also considered it inappropriate to list Dr. Sukbae Lee as a coauthor without his consent to authorship and called for further discussion. Questions about the submission process and author attribution therefore remained part of the dispute.[10]
This review addressed research-conduct issues, including submission and authorship. It did not validate LK-99’s claimed superconductivity. The fact that Kwon submitted first is therefore insufficient, on its own, to establish his motive.
Kwon’s Subsequent Work on LKK-17
Dr. Young-Wan Kwon’s later activities were reported on July 23, 2024. According to Yonhap News Agency, he held a press briefing as the head of Quantum Port, introducing a candidate material called LKK-17, which he said had fewer impurities and greater purity than LK-99.
He claimed that the material exhibited superconducting properties and said he would provide samples to experts for verification. At the same briefing, however, he stated that the samples’ electrical resistance had not been measured. His claims need to be read alongside the scope of the measurements he described.[11]
The collaborations and research activities that followed LK-99 should be traced through the public records available at each stage. Kim’s email and subsequent paper, together with Kwon’s announcement of a new candidate material, provide specific records of the paths they took after the original LK-99 preprints appeared.
Which Document Answers Which Question?
| Document type | Useful for establishing | Limit when reading it |
|---|---|---|
| The original arXiv submission histories | Submission order and the authors listed in each version. [7][8] | They do not by themselves establish the submitters’ motives. |
| Kim’s email account and the accompanying reporting | His description of his role and research relationship at that time. [1] | A participant’s account should remain attributed to that participant. |
| A conference abstract or theoretical paper | The proposal or mechanism the author puts forward. [3][6] | Publication does not by itself establish a working device or independent LK-99 replication. |
| Reporting on the authorship and research-conduct review | What the review was reported to have considered and concluded. [9][10] | Authorship findings do not determine a sample’s superconducting properties. |
References
[1] ZDNet Korea, August 10, 2025. “LK-99 Researcher Hyun-Tak Kim Reports ‘Nanovolt-Level Resistance’ and Plans for a Hyun-Tak Research Institute.” Korean-language article based on Kim’s email, including written questions and answers. Original article
[2] NIST. NIST Guide to the SI, Chapter 4: “The Two Classes of SI Units and the SI Prefixes.” See the entries for electric potential difference and electrical resistance.
[3] Hyun-Tak Kim, March 18, 2026. “Practical MOSFET Quantum Computer with Millions of Qubits.” APS Global Physics Summit 2026. Presentation abstract and author information
[4] ZDNet Korea, March 20, 2026. “An Error-Free, Million-Qubit Room-Temperature Quantum Computer Proposed: ‘Possible with Samsung’s 2-nm Process.’” In Korean.
[5] ZDNet Korea, September 27, 2026. “Stress as the Cause of Zero-Resistance Superconductivity: ‘Could a 115-Year-Old Puzzle Be Solved?’” In Korean.
[6] Hyun-Tak Kim, 2026. “Structural Symmetry Breaking Drives Spontaneous Supercurrent and the Superconducting Diode Effect.” Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics 142, 515–523. Published online September 22, 2026. DOI: 10.1134/S1063776126600820. Abstract and publication details
[7] Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon, 2023. “The First Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor.” arXiv:2307.12008v1.
[8] Sukbae Lee et al., 2023. “Superconductor Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and mechanism.” arXiv:2307.12037v1.
[9] Hankook Ilbo, December 11, 2023. “LK-99 Researchers Trade Accusations; Academics Question the Verification Process.” In Korean.
[10] Etoday, December 11, 2023. “LK-99 Paper Submitter Young-Wan Kwon Says Verification Is Underway with Commercialization in Mind.” In Korean. Original article
[11] Yonhap News Agency, July 23, 2024. “Quantum Port Claims to Have Made a Room-Temperature Superconductor: ‘Resistance Has Not Been Measured.’” In Korean. Original article
Comments
Post a Comment
자유로운 의견 해주세요