LK-99, Part 5: Sukbae Lee’s First Public Presentation

By July 2023, research by Sukbae Lee and his colleagues at the Quantum Energy Research Centre (QERC) had reached a worldwide audience under the name LK-99. The papers prompted attempts to reproduce the material and a heated debate over whether it was superconducting. Through those months, Dr. Lee had not appeared at a formal public event to explain the work himself.

That changed on January 9, 2024, when he made his first formal public presentation since LK-99 entered the global spotlight. [1]


January 9, 2024: Lee speaks at Yonsei University

Dr. Lee attended a launch event for Yonsei University's QILI initiative as the head of the Quantum Energy Research Centre. He described the development of LK-99 and outlined what his institute hoped to study next. Nearly six months had passed since the papers drew international attention. [1]

He said he remained convinced that the material his team had developed was a superconductor. He also said the institute would seek objective assessment by independent experts in Korea and abroad. His position came after multiple replication efforts had failed to confirm the original claim of superconductivity at room temperature and ambient pressure. [1]

During the presentation, Dr. Lee traced the work back to the ideas of Professor Dong-sik Choi. According to Lee, the team had spent roughly 20 years experimenting with and adjusting materials based on Choi's theory.

That account helps explain how the institute describes the history of LK-99. The length of a research effort, however, cannot establish the properties of the resulting material. [1]


A new name: PCPOSOS

The presentation also introduced PCPOSOS, which Dr. Lee described as a follow-up material made by adding sulfur to LK-99. He claimed that resistance measurements showed characteristics associated with superconductivity.

According to Lee, the team had prepared another sample on August 18, 2023, and had obtained several measurements showing zero resistance. [1] His account showed that the institute was continuing to alter the material's composition after the release of the LK-99 papers. Samples and complete measurement data were not made available for independent examination at the event. PCPOSOS remained a claim presented by the research team, rather than a material whose superconductivity had been independently established. [1]


What Lee said about the papers

Dr. Lee also addressed the confusion surrounding the LK-99 papers posted to arXiv in July 2023. He said a paper had gone online while cross-checking was under way, apologized for the problems that followed, and said related work was undergoing journal review at the time of his presentation. [1]

The public record shows that two LK-99 manuscripts with different author lists were submitted on the same day. It does not, by itself, reveal every discussion among the researchers or explain why each manuscript was submitted when it was. Those questions require a closer look at the accounts given by the people involved. [2][3]


A research plan with Yonsei University

At the event, Yonsei University's QILI initiative and the Quantum Energy Research Centre announced a plan to study superconducting materials together using a quantum computer expected at the university. The proposed work would draw on the institute's research data to search for new materials and pursue basic research toward practical applications. [1] It was a plan announced that day. The event did not present results from the proposed collaboration or an independent verification of PCPOSOS.

That distinction matters when looking back at January 9, 2024. Dr. Lee appeared in public to explain his position and the institute's next steps. His appearance gave the person leading the project a chance to speak for himself.

It did not settle the scientific question surrounding LK-99.


PCPOSOS at the APS March Meeting

On March 4, 2024, Hyun-Tak Kim presented PCPOSOS research at the American Physical Society’s March Meeting. [4] Part 6 follows Kim’s and Kwon’s later work.

Reading the Presentation as a Record of Claims and Plans

Statement at the eventStatus in this articleWhat would answer the remaining question
Dr. Sukbae Lee’s confidence in the material and account of its developmentA statement by the research team, reported on January 9, 2024. [1]Independent measurements on adequately characterized samples.
Reported zero-resistance measurements for PCPOSOSMeasurements described by the team; the event did not supply complete data and samples for independent examination. [1]Published methods, measurement limits, and reproducible electrical and magnetic results.
The announced research plan with Yonsei UniversityA proposed collaboration, as described at the event. [1]Results produced by that work; an announcement alone does not supply them.

References

[1] Yonhap News Agency, report on Dr. Lee's presentation at Yonsei University, January 9, 2024 (in Korean). Read the report

[2] Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon, “The First Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor,” arXiv:2307.12008, 2023.

[3] Sukbae Lee et al., LK-99 preprint on levitation and the proposed mechanism, arXiv:2307.12037, initial version, 2023.

[4] Yonhap News Agency, report on the PCPOSOS presentation at the APS March Meeting, March 5, 2024 (in Korean). Read the report

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

LK-99, Part 8: Patents and Applications

Superconductivity, Part 3: How Flux Pinning Works

Superconductivity, Part 1: The 1911 Discovery