LK-99, Part 7: QERC’s Patents and What They Show
Quantum Energy Research Centre (QERC), a South Korean research company, pursued patents on ceramic materials before the 2023 LK-99 papers. The records below compare those filings, examination outcomes, and later energy-materials research with KENTECH. The examination statuses of South Korean patent applications are based on Patent-ro records accessed on October 19, 2026.
Patent Filings Before the LK-99 Papers
On July 24, 2020, well before LK-99 attracted worldwide attention, QERC filed an application titled “Method for Manufacturing a Low-Resistance Ceramic Compound Including a Superconductor, and the Compound.”
The application lists QERC as the applicant and Sukbae Lee and Ji-Hoon Kim as the inventors. The granted patent was published as KR102404607B1 on June 2, 2022.[1] A divisional application from that filing, titled “Low-Resistance Ceramic Compound,” followed.
Application 10-2021-0183229 was registered as patent 10-2825784 on June 23, 2025. Its granted patent publication appeared on June 26.[2] One detail in this second patent is particularly relevant to the previous post: sulfur (S) was already included in the application’s first published set of claims.
Claim 1 of KR20210157461A, published on December 28, 2021, defined the chalcogen component, Ch, as O, S, Se, Te, Po, or combinations of these elements. Sulfur was therefore among the permitted components. The same document included examples using lead (Pb), sulfur (S), and phosphorus (P), along with elemental analysis results detecting lead, copper, sulfur, and phosphorus.[2]
The claims granted in 2025 were more specific. They defined M as Pb, Ch as S, and D as P, and required elemental analysis results showing lead, copper, sulfur, and phosphorus, together with specified measurement characteristics. Sulfur was one of several alternatives in the published application; it became a required component in the granted claims.[2]
In the previous post, Dr. Hyun-Tak Kim described his interpretation of sulfur’s role. The early patent documents record sulfur-containing compositions and examples. These sources alone do not establish who first understood that role, or when.
International Applications Published in March 2023
The international applications were also public before the LK-99 papers appeared in July 2023. WO2023027536A1 and WO2023027537A1 were published on March 2, 2023. Both concern superconducting ceramic compounds at room temperature and ambient pressure, and methods for making them.
They list QERC as the applicant and Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon as the inventors.[3] These documents were published through the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) system, administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). The PCT provides a route for pursuing patent protection in multiple countries. Whether a patent is ultimately granted is decided through examination by the relevant national or regional patent office.[4]
Different Outcomes for South Korean Patent Applications
South Korean patent records show grants, refusals, and reexamination proceedings. Some low-resistance ceramic patents were granted, while later applications received refusal decisions or entered reexamination. The following three related applications listed QERC as the lead applicant when the records were accessed on October 19, 2026. The invention titles have been shortened for the table.[5]
| Application number | Shortened invention title | Recorded status |
|---|---|---|
| 10-2021-0112104 | Low-resistance ceramic compound at room temperature and ambient pressure, and manufacturing method | Refusal decision (general) |
| 10-2022-0106812 | Ceramic compound exhibiting conductor properties at room temperature and ambient pressure, and manufacturing method | Reexamination pending after refusal |
| 10-2025-0009433 | Apatite-based ceramic compound | Refusal decision (general) |
For 10-2025-0009433, for example, the record shows that a refusal decision was sent on June 25, 2026. A request to extend the statutory deadline was filed on September 18, and approval of that extension was recorded on October 13. Procedural activity therefore continued after the refusal decision.[5]
Young-Wan Kwon’s Name in the Patent Record
Dr. Young-Wan Kwon, whose name appeared on the first LK-99 paper, also appears in the patent records.
South Korean application 10-2022-0106845, titled “Superconducting Ceramic Compound at Room Temperature and Ambient Pressure, and Method for Manufacturing the Same,”
lists Young-Wan Kwon as its lead applicant. The record displays the inventors as Sukbae Lee and two others, and the status as “refusal decision (reexamination).”[6]
The three applications in the preceding table list QERC as their lead applicant. This application lists an individual. The inventor and applicant fields record different roles: who made the invention and who applied for patent protection.
Granted Patent Publications in Japan and Australia
The overseas records include granted patent publications arising from the international filings. Examples from Japan and Australia are listed below.[7]
| Country | Granted patent publication number | Publication date |
|---|---|---|
| Japan | JP7714115B2 | July 28, 2025 |
| Japan | JP7740773B2 | September 17, 2025 |
| Australia | AU2022335232B2 | November 6, 2025 |
Energy Materials Research with KENTECH
Later patent filings also document collaboration with the Korea Institute of Energy Technology (KENTECH). KR20260020050A, published on February 10, 2026, concerns a ceramic-containing composite, a photoelectrode for the oxygen evolution reaction, and manufacturing methods. KR20260084410A, published on June 5, 2026, covers a composite electrocatalyst for the oxygen evolution reaction, a water electrolysis device incorporating it, and manufacturing methods. Both documents list KENTECH and QERC as joint applicants.[8]
The first application describes combining a semiconductor oxide with a ceramic to improve charge transfer and water-splitting performance. The second proposes using a ceramic-containing composite as an electrocatalyst for water electrolysis.[8] The later research extended into energy applications, including photoelectrodes and electrocatalysts.
QERC subsequently announced additional joint patent grants through its official newsroom. On August 28, 2026, it reported the registration of a patent concerning a layered heterostructure composite containing nickel–iron hydroxide and a ceramic. On September 16, it announced two more grants involving a hematite–ceramic photoanode and a composite photocathode for hydrogen evolution. Those announcements concerned separate applications from the two published filings described above.[9]
The Records Left by Patents and Experiments
Patent documents describe the compositions, manufacturing methods, and applications that researchers seek to protect. The United States Patent and Trademark Office explains that examination considers novelty, utility, nonobviousness, and disclosure requirements. Working models or physical specimens are generally not required.[10]
A granted patent establishes the scope of legal protection for an invention. Evidence about a sample’s superconducting behavior comes from its measurement conditions and results, together with independent replication.
References
[1] “Method for Manufacturing a Low-Resistance Ceramic Compound Including a Superconductor, and the Compound,” KR102404607B1. Granted patent publication and bibliographic information
[2] Application 10-2021-0183229, “Low-Resistance Ceramic Compound.” KR20210157461A: first published application, claims, and examples / KR102825784B1: granted claims
[3] International publications concerning superconducting ceramic compounds at room temperature and ambient pressure, and manufacturing methods. WO2023027536A1 / WO2023027537A1
[4] WIPO, Protecting Your Inventions Abroad: Frequently Asked Questions About the PCT. The PCT system and national examination
[5] Patent-ro, related South Korean patent application records. 10-2021-0112104 / 10-2022-0106812 / 10-2025-0009433 and procedural history
[6] Patent-ro, application 10-2022-0106845, “Superconducting Ceramic Compound at Room Temperature and Ambient Pressure, and Method for Manufacturing the Same.” Lead applicant and examination status
[7] Related overseas patent publications. JP7714115B2 / JP7740773B2 / AU2022335232B2 / US20240355500A1
[8] Published applications jointly filed by KENTECH and QERC. KR20260020050A / KR20260084410A
[9] QERC official newsroom. Announcement of a joint patent grant for a layered heterostructure composite / Announcement of two joint patent grants involving a photoanode and a composite photocathode
[10] USPTO, Applying for Patents, sections on “Models, exhibits, and specimens” and “Examination of applications and proceedings.” Patent application and examination guidance
Comments
Post a Comment
자유로운 의견 해주세요