Superconductivity, Part 5: Cooper Pairs and BCS Theory

In 1957, John Bardeen, Leon Cooper, and J. Robert Schrieffer explained conventional superconductivity through paired electrons in a collective quantum state. This article follows the experimental clues and the Cooper-pair idea that led to BCS theory.

1950: An Important Clue Appears

Around 1950, an important experimental result appeared in superconductivity research. Researchers found that changing the isotopic mass of the atoms in a superconducting material could change its superconducting transition temperature. This became known as the isotope effect.[1]

It was an important clue.

If changing atomic mass could change the temperature at which superconductivity appeared, then the vibrations of the crystal lattice were likely involved in the phenomenon. Atoms in a solid are not perfectly motionless. They continuously vibrate around their equilibrium positions.

In quantum mechanics, these collective vibrations of the crystal lattice are described in terms of phonons.

This raised a new question:

What do lattice vibrations have to do with electrons?

And how could this possibly be connected to the disappearance of electrical resistance?


1956: Leon Cooper Looks at Two Electrons

In 1956, American physicist Leon Cooper studied what could happen to two electrons inside a metal. This immediately presents an interesting problem. Electrons all carry the same negative electric charge, so they normally repel one another.

But inside a crystal, the situation can be different. As an electron interacts with the crystal lattice, it can produce a small distortion in that lattice. That distortion can then influence another electron.

Under certain conditions, this process can create an effective attraction between electrons. Cooper showed that even a very weak attractive interaction could allow two electrons to form a correlated state under the right conditions.[2]

This became what we now call a

Cooper pair.

But it would be misleading to imagine a Cooper pair as two tiny electrons simply stuck together like two balls. The two electrons form a quantum-mechanically correlated state and no longer behave as completely independent particles. Cooper's 1956 work provided an important clue for understanding superconductivity from the perspective of the electrons themselves.


1957: BCS Theory Appears

Then, just one year later, in 1957, one of the most important theories in the history of superconductivity appeared.

It was developed by

John Bardeen, Leon Cooper, and J. Robert Schrieffer.

The theory became known as

BCS theory.[3]

The name BCS comes from the first letters of their surnames:

Bardeen – Cooper – Schrieffer

BCS theory went beyond the idea that two electrons could form a pair. It described how large numbers of electrons could form Cooper pairs and participate in a collective quantum state, rather than behaving only as independent electrons. This provided a powerful microscopic framework for understanding how electrical resistance could disappear in the superconducting state.

BCS theory also introduced the idea of an energy gap between the superconducting state and certain excited states.

These concepts allowed physicists to move beyond the simple observation that

“electrical resistance becomes zero.”

The question could now go deeper:

“What kind of state do the electrons form inside the material that allows this phenomenon to occur?”


BCS Theory in a Simple Picture


Four-panel diagram of lattice vibrations, effective electron attraction, Cooper-pair formation, and a collective superconducting state.

BCS Theory at a Glance: From Phonons to Cooper Pairs
A simplified visual guide to the sequence explained in the BCS section.
Conceptual schematic; consult the article for the physical qualifications.


The basic flow of BCS theory, simplified for illustration. The real interaction between electrons and the crystal lattice is much more complex than this diagram suggests.

The basic idea can be summarized like this:

Crystal lattice vibrations (phonons) → effective attraction between electrons → Cooper-pair formation → collective superconducting state

The Road from 1911 to 1957

BCS theory did not appear suddenly. A series of discoveries and theories had been building up since superconductivity was first discovered.

Year Major Development in the History of Superconductivity

1911 Onnes discovers superconductivity

1933 Meissner and Ochsenfeld discover the Meissner effect

1935 The London brothers propose the London equations

1950 Ginzburg–Landau theory appears

1950 The isotope effect provides an important experimental clue

1956 Leon Cooper shows how paired electrons can form under an attractive interaction

1957 Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer publish BCS theory

Looking at this timeline makes it easier to understand why BCS theory occupies such an important place in the history of superconductivity.

Onnes's discovery → the Meissner effect → London theory → Ginzburg–Landau theory → the isotope effect → Cooper pairs → BCS theory

BCS theory was not something that suddenly appeared from nowhere. It emerged from nearly half a century of experiments, unanswered questions, and theoretical developments.


1972: The Nobel Prize in Physics

Fifteen years after BCS theory was published, John Bardeen, Leon Cooper, and J. Robert Schrieffer were jointly awarded the 1972 Nobel Prize in Physics for their development of the theory of superconductivity.[4] John Bardeen had already received the Nobel Prize in Physics once before for his work on the transistor.

With BCS theory, he received the Nobel Prize in Physics for a second time. It is a striking reminder of the importance BCS theory came to hold in the history of superconductivity. But the history of superconductivity did not end with BCS theory.

BCS theory was enormously successful in explaining conventional superconductors, but as new superconducting materials were discovered, another question began to emerge:

Can every superconductor be explained by BCS theory alone?

From this point, the history of superconductivity began to move in a new direction.


References

[1] E. Maxwell, “Isotope Effect in the Superconductivity of Mercury,” Physical Review 78, 477 (1950).

[2] Leon N. Cooper, “Bound Electron Pairs in a Degenerate Fermi Gas,” Physical Review 104, 1189–1190 (1956).

[3] J. Bardeen, L. N. Cooper & J. R. Schrieffer, “Theory of Superconductivity,” Physical Review 108, 1175–1204 (1957).

[4] Nobel Prize Outreach, “The Nobel Prize in Physics 1972.”

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

LK-99, Part 8: Patents and Applications

Superconductivity, Part 3: How Flux Pinning Works

Superconductivity, Part 1: The 1911 Discovery