Superconductivity, Part 4: Explaining Magnetic Fields
Flux Pinning: A Magnet Suspended Above a Cooled Superconductor
A frame from the position-memory demonstration discussed in the article, showing a magnet above a cooled superconductor.
Video: Jubobroff, Position memory due to pinning in a superconductor, Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 3.0. Still frame extracted from the video.
In the flux-pinning demonstration, a small magnet is displaced above a cooled superconductor and returns toward a stable position. The London equations, Ginzburg–Landau theory, and Abrikosov’s vortices help explain the magnetic interaction.
The London Brothers Explain Magnetic-Field Penetration
The fact that electrical resistance becomes zero was not enough by itself to fully explain the Meissner effect. A new theory was needed to describe how electric currents and magnetic fields behave inside a superconductor. In 1935, the German-born physicists Fritz London and his younger brother Heinz London proposed a new theoretical description of the relationship between superconducting currents and magnetic fields.[1]
The equations they introduced are now known as the London equations. This brought an important idea into the theory of superconductivity. When we say that a superconductor expels a magnetic field, it does not mean that the field suddenly drops to exactly zero the instant it reaches the surface.
Instead, the magnetic field penetrates a short distance into the material and then decreases rapidly. The characteristic distance over which this occurs is called the London penetration depth (λ).[1]
In other words, physicists were moving beyond the simple statement:
“A superconductor expels magnetic fields.”
They could now begin to describe:
“How does the magnetic field decrease inside a superconductor?”
But the London theory did not explain everything. To describe how the superconducting state itself forms and changes from one region of a material to another, another theoretical step was needed.
Ginzburg and Landau Introduce a New Approach
In 1950, Soviet physicists Vitaly Ginzburg and Lev Landau introduced a new theoretical framework for superconductivity.[2] It became known as Ginzburg–Landau theory.
Rather than trying to follow the behavior of every individual electron inside a superconductor, they described the superconducting state using a physical quantity known as an order parameter.[2] The term may sound abstract, but the basic idea is fairly intuitive. In the normal state, the superconducting order parameter is zero. Below the critical temperature, when the superconducting state appears, it becomes nonzero.
And the superconducting state does not necessarily have exactly the same strength everywhere inside a material. Near surfaces, boundaries, or regions affected by magnetic fields, the superconducting state can vary.
This leads to another important length scale:
the coherence length (ξ).
We now have two important characteristic lengths:
the penetration depth λ, which describes how far a magnetic field penetrates into a superconductor, and the coherence length ξ, which describes the characteristic distance over which the superconducting state varies in space. The relationship between these two length scales would become extremely important in understanding different types of superconductors.[2]
And This Brings Us Back to the Magnetic Vortices from Part 3
This is where the story reconnects with Part 3. Physicist Alexei Abrikosov, working with Ginzburg–Landau theory, discovered something important. In 1957, Abrikosov used the theory to describe the properties of what we now call Type-II superconductors.[2]
In a Type-II superconductor, within a certain range of magnetic fields, magnetic flux is not completely excluded from the material. Instead, magnetic flux can penetrate the superconductor in the form of quantized magnetic vortices.[2]
And when these vortices become trapped by defects or imperfections inside the material, we get the phenomenon discussed in the previous article:
flux pinning.
So the remarkable behavior we saw in the Part 3 video did not appear out of nowhere.
Behind it lies a theoretical history that developed over several decades:
Meissner and Ochsenfeld → the London brothers → Ginzburg and Landau → Abrikosov
Step by step, these developments gave physicists a more detailed picture of how superconductors interact with magnetic fields.[2]
So Why Does It Return Without Sticking to the Magnet?
Now let us return to the video.
When the superconductor is pulled away with tweezers, it is displaced from the stable magnetic configuration that had formed between the superconductor and the magnet. Once the external force is removed, the interaction involving pinned magnetic vortices and superconducting currents can produce a restoring force that tends to bring the system back toward its previous stable relative position. That is why the superconductor moves back after the tweezers release it.
But there is an important point here:
It is not simply being attracted to the magnet. In a Type-II superconductor, magnetic-field screening and the effects of magnetic vortices pinned inside the material can act together. As a result, the superconductor does not necessarily stick to the magnet or simply move away from it. Under suitable conditions, it can maintain a stable position and orientation at a certain distance from the magnet.
That is why, in the video, the superconductor can be pulled away and then return without touching the magnet, eventually settling again into a stable position in midair.
| What We See in the Video | Physical Explanation |
|---|---|
| The superconductor is pulled away from its original position | An external force changes the relative position of the superconductor and magnet |
It moves back after the tweezers release it |
A restoring force associated with flux pinning acts on the system |
It returns toward the magnet but does not stick to it |
Magnetic-field screening and pinned magnetic vortices both contribute to the interaction |
It settles again at a stable height and orientation |
Position memory associated with flux pinning |
What is remarkable about this scene is not simply that the superconductor is floating in midair. What is even more interesting is that after its position is changed, it moves back while still maintaining a stable relationship with the magnet. The motion may look simple, but behind it are magnetic vortices, flux pinning, superconducting currents, and the resulting restoring behavior.
From Magnetic Behavior to Electron Pairing
The London and Ginzburg–Landau theories described superconducting behavior without initially providing its microscopic cause. In 1957, Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer supplied a microscopic theory for conventional superconductors. [3] Part 5 explains Cooper pairs and BCS theory.
References
[3] J. Bardeen, L. N. Cooper & J. R. Schrieffer, “Theory of Superconductivity,” Physical Review 108, 1175–1204 (1957).
Image / Video Credit
Jubobroff,
Position memory due to pinning in a superconductor, Wikimedia
Commons. Licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
The image above
is a frame captured from the video.

Comments
Post a Comment
자유로운 의견 해주세요