LK-99 Patent 5: Kwon Young-wan’s Copper-Substituted Apatite

South Korean patent application KR20240028724A describes a family of apatite ceramics proposed as room-temperature superconductors at ambient pressure. Kwon Young-wan is listed as the applicant in the Korean record. One example in the application focuses on LK-99: lead apatite in which copper is proposed to occupy some of the lead sites.

1. The Korean LK-99 Patent Application

Title of the inventionRoom-Temperature, Atmospheric-Pressure Superconducting Ceramic Compound, and Method for Manufacturing the Same
Jurisdiction / filing typeRepublic of Korea
Applicant / recorded nameKwon Young-wan
DateAugust 25, 2022
Republic of Korea application number10-2022-0106845
Publication used for the technical explanationKR20240028724A
Publication dateMarch 5, 2024
Examination outcomeRefusal after re-examination, dispatched March 17, 2026.

2. What the Application Claims About Copper

The published claims describe a ceramic with the general formula A10−xBx(PO4)6O, where x ranges from 0.1 to 2.0. Lead and copper are one pairing within that broader formula. The application describes two manufacturing routes: deposition and a solid-state reaction involving lanarkite and copper phosphide.

Where Does the Copper Go?

Figure 3 of the application depicts copper replacing lead at a specific site in the crystal. The application proposes that the resulting distortion creates what it calls superconducting quantum wells and that tunneling between them could account for the claimed electrical behavior. Detecting copper in a sample only establishes that it is present. Identifying which sites it occupies requires structural measurements.

Grain boundaries and secondary phases can also affect resistance measurements. A signal from one part of a sample leaves open whether a continuous current path spans the electrodes. An independent 2023 study found that the LK-99 sample it prepared was highly resistive near room temperature and showed no evidence of superconductivity under the conditions tested.

3. Examination and Refusal

  • 2023: Examination was requested on August 16.
  • 2024: An applicant change was recorded on February 26. The application was published on March 5, and a notice inviting a response was sent on October 21.
  • 2025: A January 23 amendment was not accepted. A written response was filed on January 27, and a notice returning documents followed on March 6. A refusal was dispatched on August 6. An extension requested on October 23 was approved on October 27. A re-examination amendment was received on December 4, and a request for corrections followed on December 18.
  • 2026: A written response and amendment were filed on January 4. A refusal after re-examination was dispatched on March 17. A divisional filing was recorded on June 8, an extension requested on June 17 was approved on June 20, and a request for the examiner’s opinion was recorded on August 12.

4. What Could Be Tested First?

A practical first test would be a small electrode or a thin-film trace on a ceramic test board. A test like this could show whether the material adheres to the substrate, whether the contacts add resistance, and whether repeated heating and cooling changes its electrical behavior. Comparing samples made with different copper ratios would help show whether any change tracks copper occupancy or comes from a secondary phase.

Magnets, motors, and power cables would require reproducible superconductivity and enough current-carrying capacity under the conditions those devices actually face. The electrode and thin-film examples are proposed tests for the material, with performance still to be measured.

Dr. Kwon Young-wan has continued to file amendments in his Korean patent case. In a 2023 interview, he described a dispute with the Quantum Energy Research Centre over whose names appeared on the original patent filing. The Korean patent record lists Kwon as the applicant on the separate filing discussed here. I’m curious to see how the Korean patent office handles the case from here.

Kwon also served as CEO of the South Korean broadcaster CCS Chungbuk Broadcasting until June 2026. I’ll write more about his role at CCS in a later post.

References

  1. KR20240028724A — published application, claims, and figures
  2. Korean Patent Office — application and examination history for 10-2022-0106845
  3. Absence of Superconductivity in LK-99 at Ambient Conditions — ACS Omega (2023)


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

LK-99, Part 8: Patents and Applications

Superconductivity, Part 3: How Flux Pinning Works

Superconductivity, Part 1: The 1911 Discovery