LK-99 Patent 2 — The Broad Composition Range of Room-Temperature Ceramics

1. What Does This Patent Cover? Apatite Compositions and Manufacturing Methods

Title of the inventionCeramic Compound Exhibiting Low-Resistance Characteristics at Room Temperature and Atmospheric Pressure, and Method for Manufacturing the Same
Jurisdiction / filing typeRepublic of Korea
Applicant / recorded nameQuantum Energy Research Centre, Inc. (QERI)
DateAugust 25, 2021
Republic of Korea application number10-2021-0112104
Publication used for the technical explanationKR20230030188A
Basis of the procedural historyOfficial Patent-ro record checked on November 7, 2026. [2]
Status on November 7, 2026Decision of refusal (ordinary examination). The statutory period was extended on October 12, 2026. The official record lists a written response and amendment filed on October 26; the amendment was still marked as being processed. No re-examination decision was shown in the record checked on November 7.
Scope of this article: the published technical disclosure is discussed separately from the previously checked procedural history.
This article does not present a fresh, complete review of the latest official register or the maintenance of patent rights.
This technology concerns the composition of a ceramic containing metallic elements and oxygen, along with the methods used to produce it.
The central questions are which elements occupy which positions in the structure and how that affects the flow of current. The material’s color or its response to a magnet tells only part of the story.
The published document gives the general formula AaBb(EO4)cXd. A and B represent different groups of metallic elements,
EO4 represents an oxygen-containing group of atoms, and X represents an additional constituent. The explanation below describes the published technology
in this patent family; it does not mean that the final granted claims are identical in every country.[1]
A general formula provides a framework for describing multiple combinations rather than a single composition.
The inclusion of an element among the available choices does not establish that every possible combination has been tested successfully.
The compositions covered by the formula need to be distinguished from the samples actually made.

2. A Closer Look at the Patent: Materials, Processes, and Records Published Claims and the Amended Title

The earlier list described this application as a low-resistance ceramic, but the title and claims in the initial publication use the term superconductivity.
Reading the published application and reading later amendments means looking at the case at different stages.
This article explains the technology in the initial publication without assuming that the final amended claims are identical.
My first question is which combinations within the broad compositional range were actually tested.
The general formula includes multiple choices of elements, but readers need to examine the starting materials and results of each example to assess performance.
Broad claim coverage and broad experimental validation are different things.
This patent family discusses both deposition and solid-state reaction routes.
The solid-state route includes reacting lanarkite with copper phosphide.
Deposition can be understood as forming material on a substrate, while a solid-state reaction produces a synthesized material in bulk or powder form.[1]
Detecting the same elements does not establish that the same crystal structure has formed.
Some of the starting materials may form other compounds instead of becoming part of the intended crystal.
Composition analysis, crystal-structure analysis, and electrical measurements therefore provide different information; none can replace the others.
The magnetic and electrical results interpreted as evidence of superconductivity in the document are the applicant’s explanation.
Observing a small resistance, observing a signal that changes with temperature, and concluding that a zero-resistance path extends across the sample are different steps.
Each result needs to be considered in terms of the conclusion it can actually support.
Electrical comparisons also need to account for the form of the material.
In a thin film, changes in thickness can strongly affect the measured resistance.
For a bulk sample, its length and cross-sectional area need to be measured as well.
Resistivity accounts for these dimensions when comparing materials, so resistance and resistivity—and their units—should not be used interchangeably.
Cooling after heat treatment is another variable to consider.
Simply reporting that a material was synthesized does not mean that every sample ended up in the same state.
It is necessary to investigate whether constituents separate or other phases form during cooling, and to establish how the sample used for electrical measurements relates to the one used for structural analysis.
When reading this disclosure, I am more interested in how the results change when the conditions are adjusted slightly than in the single best performance figure.
Changing the starting-material ratio and processing conditions one at a time could help explain the role of the process if the results follow a consistent pattern.
A single exceptional sample, by itself, makes it difficult to identify which variable produced the result.
Key Events in the Official Record
January 19, 2024: notice of reasons for refusal
→ February 26, 2024: written response submitted
→ July 19, 2024: specification amended
→ January 20, 2025: final notice of reasons for refusal
→ January 22, 2025: amendment and written response submitted
→ July 11, 2025: notice of reasons for refusal
→ March 11, 2026: amendment and written response submitted
→ June 25, 2026: decision of refusal dispatched
→ September 18, 2026: request to extend the statutory period
→ October 12, 2026: extension approved.
→ October 26, 2026: written response and amendment filed; the amendment remained under processing in the November 7 record.
The procedural history reflects the official record checked on November 7, 2026; later changes may not yet appear.
Performance descriptions in the published documents are treated as the applicant’s reports and interpretations, separately from independent replication results.

3. What Could It Be Used For? Potential Applications and Conditions to Verify

One way to explore possible applications would be to compare small conductive components or coatings with existing materials.
Comparing resistance at the same length and cross-sectional area, while also measuring electrical contacts and heating, would make it easier to assess any advantage of the material itself.
These are directions for evaluation, rather than a list of products already developed.
Use as wire would require tests of continuity over long lengths, cracking under repeated bending, and contact resistance when joined to other metals.
Properties observed in a powder sample cannot simply be assumed to carry over to a power cable.
Any proposed superconducting application would also need to specify operating temperature, magnetic field, and allowable current. When assessing the future value of this patent family,
I would first look for independent replication, comparisons made under the same conditions, and repeated production at a consistent quality.
Counting patent records across countries cannot substitute for assessing these engineering requirements.
Cost comparisons need to include more than the price of the starting materials.
They also need to account for the proportion of the reaction product that can actually be used. If only the best portions are selected, the usable yield may be much lower than the total amount synthesized.
Separation, grinding, and the handling of rejected material all need to be included when evaluating the economics of the manufacturing process.

References

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

LK-99, Part 8: Patents and Applications

Superconductivity, Part 3: How Flux Pinning Works

Superconductivity, Part 1: The 1911 Discovery