LK-99, Part 3: The Viral Videos
LK-99 videos spread rapidly in 2023. This timeline separates filming dates, publication dates, and what the clips actually showed.
Filmed in January, posted in February
On February 27, 2023, Quantum Energy Research Centre posted a YouTube video titled Magnetic Property Test of LK-99 Film. The filming date shown in the video was January 26, 2023. [1][2] The clip shows a material formed on a copper plate responding to a magnet. Its title describes it as a test of the magnetic properties of an LK-99 film.
In an interview conducted on August 5, 2023, Hyun-Tak Kim told Newsis that, as he understood it, this film video was a staged illustration of what might happen with a superconductor, rather than actual experimental data. The interview was published on August 6. [2] His comment concerned the film video posted in February. It should not be applied to the later ScienceCast video of a small sample.
Another video was filmed in March
In the same interview, Hyun-Tak Kim said that the video he posted on ScienceCast had been filmed in March. [2] That video shows a small gray sample on a magnet. One side remains in contact with the magnet while the other is raised. [3]
The clip would become one of the most widely shared images associated with LK-99, but several months passed between its filming and the attention it received online.
July 25 — The ScienceCast video draws early questions
By July 25, 2023, viewers were commenting on the LK-99 video page on ScienceCast. The page presented the video alongside the abstract of the related paper. [3]
Comments from that day show both interest and uncertainty. One commenter was intrigued but wanted independent confirmation. Others asked why only part of the sample was raised or suggested sending samples to outside laboratories. [3]
ScienceCast was a place to discuss what the video showed as well as a place to watch it.
August 1 — A video from China reaches millions of views
On August 1, 2023, researchers at Huazhong University of Science and Technology posted a video of an LK-99-related sample on Bilibili. The work was led by Professor Haixin Chang, with Hao Wu, Li Yang, and others participating. A related ScienceCast posting also lists the researchers. [4][5]
According to a report published at the time by The Paper, the team began livestreaming its experiments on July 31, before releasing the video. Viewers could follow parts of the work as the sample was prepared and tested. [5]
The video drew a large audience. The Paper reported that by about 1 p.m. China time on August 2, it had received more than 6.5 million views and roughly 48,000 comments. [5]
It was another video from researchers outside Korea showing a similar kind of movement. Some commenters celebrated, while others asked for electrical resistance measurements. Interest in the footage also brought questions about what the researchers would measure next. [5]
August 3 — Another clip appears in the U.S. press
The videos moved beyond research pages and video platforms into news coverage. According to Newsis, The New York Times featured an additional clip supplied by Hyun-Tak Kim on August 3, 2023, U.S. local time. [2]
In his Newsis interview, Kim said the footage had been filmed recently and that he had shared it to address the controversy surrounding the earlier videos. [2] People following the story through news articles could now see LK-99 footage without visiting the original research pages.
September — Social media attention becomes part of the story
On September 11, 2023, Nature Physics published an editorial titled “Party like it’s LK-99.” It discussed the strong response on social media to the claim of a room-temperature, ambient-pressure superconductor. [6] The response showed how scientific news could reach people beyond research circles. A viewer did not have to understand the paper’s equations or graphs to see the sample move. The same short clips could be shared and discussed across languages and platforms.
The videos helped carry the LK-99 story from research pages into a global public conversation.
A Reader’s Guide to the Evidence in a Levitation Clip
The videos in this timeline matter as public records: they show what viewers encountered and when. To evaluate the physics, I separate the visible motion from measurements that the clip does not provide.
| What a clip can show | What a viewer cannot determine from that alone | Evidence to look for alongside it |
|---|---|---|
| A sample tilts or one edge rises | Whether electrical resistance has vanished | Transport measurements with the measurement geometry and sensitivity stated. |
| A sample moves when a magnet approaches | Whether the response is superconducting or arises from another magnetic mechanism | Magnetic measurements, sample characterization, and appropriate comparisons. |
| A similar-looking result appears in another laboratory | Whether the same composition and superconducting state were reproduced | A synthesis description and independently reported electrical and magnetic results. |
This is why I treat the videos as a timeline of observations and public attention. The scientific verification timeline in Part 2 supplies the separate experimental context. A film’s publication date, its filming date, and the date of a scientific result should also remain distinct.
References
[4] Hao Wu, Li Yang, Bichen Xiao, and Haixin Chang. (2023). Successful growth and room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99. ScienceCast.
[5] The Paper (澎湃新闻). (August 2, 2023). “全球首个复现韩国室温超导磁悬浮?华中科大实验视频发布了什么” (in Chinese).
[6] Nature Physics. (September 11, 2023). “Party like it’s LK-99”. Nature Physics, 19, 1222.
Comments
Post a Comment
자유로운 의견 해주세요