LK-99, Part 1: Dong-sik Choi and the Origins
LK-99 drew worldwide attention in 2023, but its research roots reach back to Dong-sik Choi, a chemistry professor at Korea University. This article follows his ideas and the researchers who pursued them. Now, I want to turn to LK-99, the material that captured worldwide attention in 2023.
On July 22, 2023, a team of South Korean researchers released a paper claiming to have developed a material capable of superconductivity at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. What made the announcement even more unusual was that two separate LK-99 papers appeared on the same day, just two hours and twenty minutes apart. The first paper listed Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon as its authors. The second listed Sukbae Lee, Jihoon Kim, Hyun-Tak Kim, Sungyeon Im, SooMin An, and Keun Ho Auh. [5][6]
The two papers helped bring LK-99 to international attention. Yet the research behind LK-99 did not begin in 2023. Its roots stretched back to work carried out in South Korea during the 1990s.
At the center of that earlier research was Professor Dong-sik Choi (1943–2017), a chemist at Korea University. Before examining the experiments, scientific claims, and controversy surrounding LK-99, it is worth getting to know the professor whose ideas helped inspire the researchers behind it.
Who Was Professor Dong-sik Choi?
Professor Dong-sik Choi was born in Seoul in 1943. He studied chemistry at Seoul National University and later earned a doctorate from the University of Virginia in the United States. He joined Korea University's Department of Chemistry as an assistant professor in 1972 and became an associate professor in 1975.
His academic interests extended beyond general and physical chemistry. He studied statistical thermodynamics, fluid behavior, and the physical properties of matter. He also explored whether principles used to describe physical systems could be applied to social and economic phenomena.
In 1986, he received the fifth Sejong Cultural Award in the cultural category. [1] Choi's main academic career focused on chemistry, thermodynamics, and eventually superconductivity. His involvement in superconductivity became especially notable when he began questioning whether existing theories could fully explain the phenomenon.
Questioning the Limits of BCS Theory
As discussed earlier in this series, John Bardeen, Leon Cooper, and Robert Schrieffer introduced BCS theory in 1957. Their theory explained conventional superconductivity through the formation of Cooper pairs, in which electrons enter a collective quantum state that allows electrical current to flow without resistance. BCS theory was one of the major achievements of twentieth-century condensed-matter physics.
However, the discovery of high-temperature superconductors in 1986 raised questions that the conventional electron–phonon mechanism could not adequately answer. Choi became interested in these limitations of existing superconductivity theory. In a 1993 interview published in the Korean science magazine Science Donga, he expressed the view that existing BCS theory alone could not adequately explain all aspects of superconductivity. [2]
He wanted to explore the phenomenon from a different theoretical perspective. This distinction matters. The inability of conventional BCS theory to explain every superconducting material does not mean that BCS theory itself is incorrect. It remains a well-established explanation of conventional superconductors.
Choi approached the problem through subjects he had studied for years: statistical thermodynamics and the viscosity of liquids. Viscosity describes a fluid's resistance to flowing. Choi considered whether related concepts might offer insights into how electrons behave collectively inside a material.
In a later presentation, Dr. Sukbae Lee explained that Choi's work on liquid viscosity had led him to consider a possible connection between fluid resistance and the behavior of an electron fluid. [3] This line of thinking became part of the foundation for Choi's alternative approach to superconductivity.
Developing a Different Theory of Superconductivity
In 1994, Choi published a book titled The Theoretical Framework of the Superconductivity Revolution (초전도 혁명의 이론적 체계). The book examined existing explanations of superconductivity and presented his own theoretical approach. Chapter 4 discussed a new concept of superconductivity, while Chapter 5 introduced what Choi called ISB superconductivity theory. [4]
Choi drew on his research into fluid equations of state and viscosity as he explored how electrons might behave collectively. According to Lee's later presentation, Choi and his collaborators looked for similarities between patterns observed in changes of liquid states and changes in the electronic states of superconducting materials. Their broader goal was to understand how the structure of a material could influence electron behavior.
ISB theory did not become an established or experimentally validated replacement for conventional superconductivity theory. Nor has it been independently demonstrated to explain room-temperature superconductivity. Nevertheless, Choi continued investigating whether his theoretical ideas could guide the search for new superconducting materials.
One of the researchers who became involved in that work was Dr. Sukbae Lee.
How Professor Choi and Sukbae Lee Became Connected
Sukbae Lee, who would later become one of the central figures in the LK-99 announcement, became involved with Choi's research at Korea University. Choi believed that superconductivity might be achievable through a mechanism different from the conventional BCS approach. Lee joined the effort to explore that possibility through experiments.
Ji-Hoon Kim later became another important member of the research group. Their work involved preparing materials, modifying their structures, and examining electrical and magnetic properties that might indicate unusual electronic behavior. According to Lee's later account, something unexpected occurred in 1999.
During their experiments, the researchers observed an unusual effect involving an extremely small amount of material. Lee recalled that the amount was so tiny that producing a metric ton of material might yield only about one milligram of the substance they were interested in. This was Lee's description of an early experimental observation, not independently verified evidence of superconductivity.
Nevertheless, the result apparently gave the researchers a reason to continue investigating. That same year, Lee entered military service, temporarily interrupting his research.
The Story of Sukbae Lee's Return After Military Service
In a research presentation made public in January 2024, Lee shared a personal story about what happened after his military service. According to his account, he entered the military in 1999 and spent approximately three years away from the laboratory. By the time he completed his service, he no longer intended to return to the research.
Then, one day after his discharge, his mentor came to his home. Lee recalled that he eventually returned to the research project. [3] It is a memorable episode in the history surrounding LK-99.
Lee recounted the experience with humor, but the story also offers a glimpse into the relationship between a mentor and a young researcher who had considered leaving the project behind. After returning, Lee continued preparing materials and investigating their physical properties. The unusual experimental signal that the researchers said they had observed in 1999 became part of a research effort that continued for more than two decades.
The Founding of the Quantum Energy Research Centre
In 2008, Lee and his colleagues established the Quantum Energy Research Centre, often referred to as Q-Centre. The research that had begun within the academic environment of Korea University now continued through a separate research organization. The team investigated different materials and preparation methods, seeking conditions under which superconductivity might occur at ordinary temperatures and pressures.
In his later presentation, Lee also discussed Choi's interest in whether certain electrical properties could arise in liquid systems. According to Lee, the researchers experimented with different types of materials, including liquid-state systems, as they explored these ideas. They also investigated possible applications involving the relationship between heat and electricity.
Choi eventually retired from his university position but remained connected with researchers pursuing related work.
2017 — Professor Choi's Final Research Activities
Another account shared by Lee concerns events in 2017. Lee recalled that Choi had expressed an interest in restarting an earlier line of research. The group made plans to present their research to the Korea Electric Power Corporation (KEPCO).
However, Choi passed away unexpectedly after the presentation had been arranged. Lee later organized the research materials and went ahead with the planned presentation. According to his account, the presentation reflected Choi's long-standing interest in investigating whether superconductivity could exist under comparatively warm conditions. [3]
Choi's death did not bring the research to an end. Lee and his colleagues continued their experiments, working to improve material synthesis and measurement techniques. One important part of LK-99's history is that the research inspired by Choi continued after his death.
The Origin of the Name LK-99
The name LK-99 contains both the names of the researchers and a reference to the early history of the project. L stands for Lee, K stands for Kim, and 99 refers to 1999. The researchers identified 1999 as the year when they first observed something that suggested the material might have unusual properties.
But another story from the development of LK-99 concerns an unexpected laboratory accident. According to the research team's account, experiments resumed more intensively in 2017, and some of the results arose under unusual conditions. During high-temperature synthesis, sealed quartz tubes sometimes broke, apparently because of rapid cooling or pressure changes inside the tubes.
The team reported observing materials with unusual magnetic properties under these conditions. A broken tube could expose its contents to the surrounding air, but it has not been established that oxygen entering the tube directly caused the observed properties. In their 2023 Korean-language paper, Consideration for the Development of Room-Temperature, Ambient-Pressure Superconductor (LK-99), the researchers described how unexpected experimental observations helped guide their continued investigation. [8]
There is an important scientific distinction here. The unusual magnetic behavior observed in those experiments was not, by itself, evidence of superconductivity. The researchers subsequently described the behavior observed around 2018 as superparamagnetism, rather than the characteristic response expected from a superconductor.
Superparamagnetism can occur in very small magnetic particles and is different from the Meissner effect associated with superconductivity. Even so, the unexpected results reportedly encouraged further investigation into the material's structure and synthesis conditions. The team continued adjusting compositions, changing preparation methods, and studying the origin of the unusual observations.
The early observations in 1999 and the experiments involving broken quartz tubes after 2017 were separate stages of the research. The quartz-tube incident belongs to the later experimental period, not to 1999. Over time, the researchers also pursued patent applications concerning the material and its preparation methods.
2023 — Two Papers That Brought LK-99 to the World
After years of research, the first LK-99 paper appeared on arXiv on July 22, 2023. Titled The First Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor, it listed Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon as authors. [5] The paper claimed that LK-99 exhibited superconductivity at room temperature and atmospheric pressure.
Approximately two hours and twenty minutes later, a second paper was submitted. This paper listed six authors: Sukbae Lee, Jihoon Kim, Hyun-Tak Kim, Sungyeon Im, SooMin An, and Keun Ho Auh. Its title was Superconductor Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and mechanism. [6]
The second paper described the proposed crystal structure, preparation method, reported magnetic levitation, and a possible explanation for superconductivity. The researchers suggested that replacing some lead ions with copper ions inside the lead-apatite structure could create distortions associated with superconducting behavior. They discussed the proposed mechanism using one-dimensional BR-BCS theory.
Both papers claimed a superconducting critical temperature of 400 K or higher. The second paper was subsequently revised on July 29 and August 11, 2023. Young-Wan Kwon was not included among the authors of the second paper. We will examine why he did not participate in that paper in a later article.
The near-simultaneous release of the two papers became a defining moment in the history of LK-99. However, independent laboratories around the world were unable to confirm the claimed room-temperature, ambient-pressure superconductivity. Later studies showed that several unusual observations could be explained by impurities or conventional magnetic behavior rather than superconductivity. [7]
As a result, LK-99 has not been scientifically established as a room-temperature, ambient-pressure superconductor.
Choi’s Influence on LK-99
Choi’s ideas helped guide Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and their colleagues. His ISB theory did not become an experimentally established explanation of superconductivity. The history of that research is separate from whether LK-99 meets experimental tests for superconductivity.
References
[1] Korea University Press. Choi Dong-sik — Author Profile. https://kupress.com/writers/최동식/
[3] Sukbae Lee. Superconductor Research Presentation and Recorded Remarks, made public in January 2024. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCtIN-baaAM
[5] Lee, S., Kim, J.-H., & Kwon, Y.-W. (2023). The First Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor. arXiv:2307.12008.
[6] Lee, S., Kim, J., Kim, H.-T., Im, S., An, S., & Auh, K. H. (2023). Superconductor Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and mechanism. arXiv:2307.12037.
[7] Garisto, D. (2023). LK-99 Isn’t a Superconductor — How Science Sleuths Solved the Mystery. Nature.
[8] Lee, S., et al. (2023). Consideration for the Development of Room-Temperature, Ambient-Pressure Superconductor (LK-99). Journal of the Korean Crystal Growth and Crystal Technology, 33(2), 61–70. https://doi.org/10.6111/JKCGCT.2023.33.2.061
Comments
Post a Comment
자유로운 의견 해주세요